Overdue
Interest
by Matt Miller
In
America many people are ignorant of the horrible crimes committed
by the Japanese Imperial Army during their invasion of China.
In Japan, many even try to deny the Great Nanjing Massacre.
Iris Chang wrote The Rape of Nanking to remind people
of the evil done 60 years ago and the following is a comment
on her book.
The Japanese Imperial
Army made a prominent spot in the
of collective evil 60 years ago when it launched the Great
Nanjing .
In less than two months, Japanese troops killed from 150 000
to 300 000 unarmed Chinese civilians and raped and tortured
more than 100 000 women. It was an act of mass barbarism that
much of Japan to this day either can't explain or simply won't
admit could have happened.
In the United States,
a series of conferences timed to the anniversary of the massacre
- which began on December 13 and lasted for about six weeks
- is attempting to revive long-dormant interest in this horrific
event. Most Americans have absolutely no idea about either
the December 1937 - January 1938 massacre or its relationship
to World War II. Central
to this attempted revival is a new book by Iris Chang,
The Rape of Nanking.
Chang, 29, lives in the
California Silicon Valley city of Sunnyvale, 100 kilometers
south of San Francisco. It's no coincidence that a Chinese-American
writer in America's technology heartland is leading the charge
that demands both Japanese acknowledgment of responsibility
and mainstream American recognition. Chang and her book are
indications of an important movement within America. It is
a demand for shared history. As
groups gain economic, social and political confidence, they
prod and push for their historic tales to be heard.
"This is an invitation
to Americans as a whole to become larger by incorporating the
history of others," says Vera Schwarcz, a professor of
Chinese history at Wesleyan University in Connecticut. Nowhere
is this movement more visible than among some of the more affluent
Asian-American communities in California. "I go into school
libraries and I'm shocked at how little there is," says
Los Angeles-based Korean-American writer Helie Lee. Her critically-acclaimed
memoir, Still Life With Rice, is a fascinating tale
of her grandmother, who overcame extraordinary adversity at
the hands of Japanese. "It
is up to us as Asian-Americans to supply the resources, it is
up to us to speak."
The Nanjing massacre provides
a compelling focus for Chinese-Americans, who pressured the
San Francisco Unified School District into including the massacre
in high-school history courses. Similar demands are being
made in Southern California's Orange County. Now, Chang is
offering this history for mainstream consumption.
For Chang, the Nanjing
massacre began with self-discovery. The daughter of Taiwan
scientists who came to America in the 1960s, Chang heard stories
about the massacre - how the Yangtze River ran red with blood-and
how her grandparents had miraculously escaped the carnage.
Her grandfather - a journalist
stationed in the then Nationalist capital of Nanjing - was
being evacuated by boat from Wuhu. Her grandmother and infant
aunt were making their way from their ancestral village by
sampan. Her grandfather waited on the docks for four days.
Time was running out. "In despair, he screamed his beloved's
name - Yi-Pei - to the heavens," Chang writes. "Then,
like an echo from far away, he heard a reply. It came from
one last sampan approaching the docks."
But as a child, Chang could
find nothing that tied those personal accounts to history
as Americans understand it. "While still in grade school
I searched the local public libraries to see what I could
learn about the massacre, but nothing turned up," she
says. "It made me wonder. If it was really as bad as
my parents said it was, then why couldn't I find it in the
library?"
Three years ago, Chang
had just finished Thread of the Silkworm, a book on
Chinese-American scientist Tsien Hsue-shen (Qian Xueshen),
a victim of the
era in the 1950s who then helped China develop its missile
program. She attended a conference on the Nanjing Massacre
in the Silicon Valley community of Cupertina, organized by
the Global Alliance for Preserving the History of World War
II in Asia, an umbrella group of 30 organizations.
"We feel that if
we don't hold these people, this government, responsible,
future generations will say, ‘Well, these people got away
with it, so can we,'" explains Ignatius Ding, an engineer
and an alliance founder. Ding adds, "The continued denial
is an insult to our heritage."
The 1994 conference showcased
dramatic and gruesome photographs of the massacre. "Nothing
prepared me for these pictures," Chang writes in her
book, "stark black-and-white images of decapitated heads,
bellies ripped open, and nude women forced by their rapists
into various pornographic poses, their faces twisted into
unforgettable expressions of agony and shame."
Chang was appalled. "It
was worse than I could ever have imagined," she says.
"I felt sick to my stomach. I remember walking around
in a state of shock." But the photos also hooked her
on the need to relate this horror to other Americans. "I
remember being very angry, especially at the intensity of
the massacre, that more than 300 000 people may have died
in the slaughter and that this could so easily be ignored.
I felt I had almost a moral obligation as a Chinese-American
writer to let the rest of the world know what happened. And
I felt a kind of urgency."
She spent the next two
years researching the massacre. Her conclusion: "This
went beyond just a mere slaughter. This is one of the greatest
atrocities the world has ever seen."
The young author describes
her emotional and historical quest over lunch in a seafood
restaurant near the apartment complex where she and her engineer
husband, Bretton Lee Douglas, live. Chang talks in often-indignant
tones, only occasionally picking at the fried squid in front
of her. Her stories are laced with outrage, most often directed
at Japan's dogged refusal to come to terms with its past.
"It's appalling that
the Japanese continue to deny that it happened, that they
really have escaped moral and financial responsibility,"
she says. Japan is "sending out the message to countries
in the future that if you're rich and powerful enough, you
can go ahead and kill and rape or torture hundreds of thousands
of men, women and children and get away with it 60 years later."
Chang's research uncovered
a 2 000-page diary of John Rabe, a German businessman who
spearheaded expatriate efforts in Nanjing to counter the Japanese
army's insanity. His account adds to the growing body of non-Chinese
accounts that support the case of a systematic carnage by
Japanese troops. Rabe's witnessing is all the more credible
as he both headed the International Committee for the Nanking
Safety Zone and the local Nazi Party.
Chang believes the Nanjing
Massacre is indicative that the Japanese conquerors purposely
dehumanized the Chinese. The
massacre was also a systematic attempt at annihilation, Chang
argues, adding that the massacre should be likened to
.
Yet there is Japan's continued
denial. Chang
believes it stems from legal concerns: If Japan were to admit
responsibility, the door would be open to lawsuits demanding
billions of dollars in reparations. But that is
an oversimplification. Japan continues to
in its own mythology
of the Japanese as victims. The country maintains a
belief that it was pushed into military adventure.
Palace politics also plays
a role. The late Emperor Hiroh-ito's uncle, Prince Yasuhiko
Asaka, commanded the army around Nanjing. Orders, stamped
with his seal, told officers to kill all captured Chinese
soldiers. Even if one assumes that Japanese authorities lost
control and their troops went crazy, why was the carnage allowed
to continue for so long? Who or what finally stopped it?
All these issues are of
little interest to most Americans, who suffer from what Schwarcz
terms an "allergy to history." The Rape of Nanking
stands as one of the only nonfiction accounts of the
massacre in the English language. Yet it is barely 200 pages
long, and appears to be aimed at an audience with little historical
perspective. Chang
and other Chinese-Americans ask that fellow citizens understand
this horror in the most fundamental terms. The
first task, they are saying, is basic education.
(1 322 words)
|